AppSheet vs Excel? When a Spreadsheet Is No Longer Enough
Author: Grzegorz Ługowski - Founder & Lead Engineer, GL Omniflow.
Excel is great at calculations, but struggles when multiple people work simultaneously on mobile devices. AppSheet does not replace spreadsheets - it turns them into apps.
The short answer: stick with Excel if only one or a few people use the file on a desktop computer and the main task is calculations. Consider AppSheet when data is collected by multiple people, often in the field, and you need permissions, statuses, and a change history.
How do AppSheet and Excel differ on the key points?
| Criterion | Excel | AppSheet |
|---|---|---|
| Mobile use | inconvenient | forms, photos, barcode scanning, GPS |
| Multiple users at once | risk of overwriting and conflicting file versions | each user adds records in their own view |
| Permissions | access to the entire file | each role only sees their own data |
| Change history | hard to trace who changed a value | logs changes and status updates |
| Calculations and analysis | usually the better choice | weaker - keep analysis in the spreadsheet |
| Cost | usually already paid for | per-user Google license plus implementation |
Do you have to choose just one?
No. A common setup is AppSheet for data collection and Google Sheets or Excel for reports. The data remains in the spreadsheet, while the team gets a convenient app.
When is it better to optimize Excel itself?
When the main challenge is complex calculations rather than data collection. In a project for a jewellery retail chainy retail chain, we streamlined an Excel bonus calculation system with numerous edge cases - an app was not needed.