AppSheet vs Excel? When a Spreadsheet Is No Longer Enough

Author: - Founder & Lead Engineer, GL Omniflow.

Excel is great at calculations, but struggles when multiple people work simultaneously on mobile devices. AppSheet does not replace spreadsheets - it turns them into apps.

The short answer: stick with Excel if only one or a few people use the file on a desktop computer and the main task is calculations. Consider AppSheet when data is collected by multiple people, often in the field, and you need permissions, statuses, and a change history.

How do AppSheet and Excel differ on the key points?

CriterionExcelAppSheet
Mobile useinconvenientforms, photos, barcode scanning, GPS
Multiple users at oncerisk of overwriting and conflicting file versionseach user adds records in their own view
Permissionsaccess to the entire fileeach role only sees their own data
Change historyhard to trace who changed a valuelogs changes and status updates
Calculations and analysisusually the better choiceweaker - keep analysis in the spreadsheet
Costusually already paid forper-user Google license plus implementation

Do you have to choose just one?

No. A common setup is AppSheet for data collection and Google Sheets or Excel for reports. The data remains in the spreadsheet, while the team gets a convenient app.

When is it better to optimize Excel itself?

When the main challenge is complex calculations rather than data collection. In a project for a jewellery retail chainy retail chain, we streamlined an Excel bonus calculation system with numerous edge cases - an app was not needed.